Details from Variety.
Good Omens graphic novel update
Jan. 30th, 2025 06:20 pmUpdate today from the Good Omens graphic novel Kickstarter, as they finally address the huge elephant in the room, and the Neil Gaiman sexual assault allegations. They're reopening refund offers temporarily, and he won't be benefiting financially from the Kickstarter. It's still fraught, but that has calmed a lot of people's nerves. I plan (and did before today) to continue receiving my pledge. Because the original book was mostly written by Terry Pratchett. I feel very sorry for Rhianna Pratchett and Rob Wilkins having to deal with this, as well as the graphic novel artist Colleen Doran who is dealing with cancer throughout this. But yes, I'm still getting my book, and will be keeping it. Along with the Tadfield village mug I ordered as an add-on. Because of Pterry.
More Neil Gaiman news
Jan. 13th, 2025 06:53 pmThere's new Neil Gaiman reporting out today. Far more devastating than reported previously. The investigative journalism and reporting looks solid. The content is potentially very triggering for readers. So be prepared for that and bail out at any time. Huge sympathies for all sexual assault victims. Note I'm not linking to it. But it's easily findable via Google. But please beware it is potentially very distressing to read.
Dead Boy Detectives cancelled by Netflix
Aug. 31st, 2024 11:14 amAfter just one series. Radio Times report.
Not surprising, not least given the quagmire of accusations circling around Neil Gaiman since July. Which are continuing to produce new ones.
That's also why we haven't rushed to watch it to be fair ...
Sandman and Good Omens TV series may be safer. To be fair Good Omens just needs one more series. And it has been commissioned. Sandman has finished filming season 2 I think.
Not surprising, not least given the quagmire of accusations circling around Neil Gaiman since July. Which are continuing to produce new ones.
That's also why we haven't rushed to watch it to be fair ...
Sandman and Good Omens TV series may be safer. To be fair Good Omens just needs one more series. And it has been commissioned. Sandman has finished filming season 2 I think.
I haven't posted about this publicly before. Mainly because I don't know what to say, and I'm still trying to process it. And I haven't felt that I can contribute to the discussion. Google it if you need to know more. Be warned the details are potentially highly triggering and distressing.
However at best I think there is a serious question mark over any perception of consent. Assuming consent in the circumstances described - hugely skewed in terms of age, power, and employer/employee relations, is highly questionable, and I think untenable. At worst it's potentially criminal sexual assault.
For now I am looking at his books and comics from a very wary distance. Including my recently personally signed and dedicated book.
I will be very surprised if one of his TV series continues, and am doubtful for the other two.
Just currently really disappointed.
However at best I think there is a serious question mark over any perception of consent. Assuming consent in the circumstances described - hugely skewed in terms of age, power, and employer/employee relations, is highly questionable, and I think untenable. At worst it's potentially criminal sexual assault.
For now I am looking at his books and comics from a very wary distance. Including my recently personally signed and dedicated book.
I will be very surprised if one of his TV series continues, and am doubtful for the other two.
Just currently really disappointed.
Doctor Who rewatch: The Girl Who Waited
Apr. 15th, 2024 04:08 amJust finished watching this tonight, the Matt Smith story that sees Amy separated from the Doctor and Rory, and time shenanigans mean that Amy ends up spending a very very long time trapped ...
This was my favourite episode of that year on first watch. It even beat Neil Gaiman's "The Doctor's Wife" for me. And I think I voted in the Hugos that year, when both stories were on the Best Dramatic Presentation (Short Form) shortlist. And I knew which I preferred, though the Gaiman story won the Hugo award in the end.
It's still powerful to rewatch today. The opening third is standard scifi setup, but when you meet the older version of Amy the emotional level escalates rapidly. I think I probably related to that more this time, because I'm closer in age to that version of Amy than I was when this first aired.
The direction is a joy, and one scene in particular stands out for me, when the two Amys - young and old - are able to talk to each other across time. Originally an older actress was intended to play older Amy, but Karen Gillan wanted to give it a go. And with the aid of prosthetic makeup does a fantastic job. By far her best acting in Doctor Who ever.
It's also remarkable as a low budget and Doctor lite episode. Matt Smith is very much in it, but the story is carried by Amy (both versions) and Rory, and both act superbly. I should also praise the writer Tom MacRae. I wasn't that keen on his Cybermen two-parter with David Tennant, but this - his other story - is stellar.
The ending is inevitable, but how you get there is in turns moving and shocking. And throughout so brilliantly acted.
This remains an absolute highlight for me of the Matt Smith era. There were some gems, even if there were some clunkers too.
This was my favourite episode of that year on first watch. It even beat Neil Gaiman's "The Doctor's Wife" for me. And I think I voted in the Hugos that year, when both stories were on the Best Dramatic Presentation (Short Form) shortlist. And I knew which I preferred, though the Gaiman story won the Hugo award in the end.
It's still powerful to rewatch today. The opening third is standard scifi setup, but when you meet the older version of Amy the emotional level escalates rapidly. I think I probably related to that more this time, because I'm closer in age to that version of Amy than I was when this first aired.
The direction is a joy, and one scene in particular stands out for me, when the two Amys - young and old - are able to talk to each other across time. Originally an older actress was intended to play older Amy, but Karen Gillan wanted to give it a go. And with the aid of prosthetic makeup does a fantastic job. By far her best acting in Doctor Who ever.
It's also remarkable as a low budget and Doctor lite episode. Matt Smith is very much in it, but the story is carried by Amy (both versions) and Rory, and both act superbly. I should also praise the writer Tom MacRae. I wasn't that keen on his Cybermen two-parter with David Tennant, but this - his other story - is stellar.
The ending is inevitable, but how you get there is in turns moving and shocking. And throughout so brilliantly acted.
This remains an absolute highlight for me of the Matt Smith era. There were some gems, even if there were some clunkers too.
Rewatching Doctor Who: The Doctor's Wife
Dec. 28th, 2023 09:16 amThis post is full of spoilers, so I'll put it in a cut. Note there are spoilers for almost all the Matt Smith run in there, so beware.
( Spoilers... )
Watching Neil Gaiman chat about fantasy
Nov. 21st, 2023 11:38 pmMartin and I have just enjoyed watching last night’s recording (for paid ticket holders only - I had bought an online viewing ticket) of Neil Gaiman at the British Library chatting with Roz Kaveney about fantasy. It was lovely. Takeaways included:
- Neil has a half completed Neverwhere sequel novel that he hopes to get back to after writing Good Omens season 3 (yes 3!).
- As a youngster Neil thought he’d be a scifi writer later in life. Ditto for Terry Pratchett. Both of whom ended up pretty resolutely as fantasy writers.
- The only Discworld book Neil had a serious hand in was Pyramids, which he helped plan the plot for.
- So many insights into the origins of Sandman - even loads I hadn’t heard in Neil’s one hour detailed chat at the Edinburgh Book Festival just about Sandman.
- Neil thinks we are approaching the end of social media as we knew it. In particular he spoke of Twitter as “It’s a thing that we used to have in the olden days that was good.” Quite!
- I still have some Neil Gaiman graphic novels yet to read - must prioritise! His discussion of his family history links with Violent Cases and Mr Punch was eye opening.
- And yes, we need to watch the last part bonus episode for Sandman season 1 (“Calliope”) which was mentioned in the chat, and also Good Omens season 2 (also mentioned).
Tomorrow night we will be watching the recording from tonight of Neil Gaiman chatting with Rob Wilkins about Terry Pratchett and his worlds. Should be fab. Again I had pre bought an online ticket. These events are part of the wider Fantasy exhibition season at the British Library, and are going ahead despite the library’s ongoing cyber attack problems. I’m finding it astonishing that I’m able to watch and enjoy these talks viewing from northern Scotland.
Just finished my 50th book of the year - completing my 2023 Goodreads reading challenge, though I will be carrying on reading more yet. And it's a reread, a much adored book that I reread every October in the run-up to Halloween.
It was the last book published by Roger Zelazny, and tells of a group of Gothic horror characters, some familiar, some new, gathered together in the countryside near Victorian London, to undertake a mysterious ritual at Halloween involving Elder Gods and much more. It's a Gothic delight, and also like reading a gigantic chess puzzle in literary form. Each of the human participants in the Game has an animal companion, and the book is narrated by Jack the Ripper's dog Snuff.
Strictly speaking I should read it a chapter a day throughout October. I rarely manage it, though I tried pacing again this year, and still ended up gobbling it up far quicker. It's just so much fun. I also realised this time just how many favourite parts I have, as I was so happy to encounter them again.
This year we have also set my husband's boss onto reading it. He's a big Roger Zelazny fan, and has been interested in this book since Martin told him about it. This year a brand new 30th anniversary paperback edition was released, with new introduction by Neil Gaiman, my favourite living author. I had to upgrade my paperback copy to that (I also have a first edition hardback copy, much cherished), and so we passed on my copy to Martin's boss. Who was delighted to get it in hand just in time for October and a first read ...
So yes, a magnificent book, that I would recommend to anyone who likes a spooky tale, Gothic horror, or just plain good storytelling. Rereading it each year is a joy for me. Even if I can rarely pace myself to read it slowly!

It was the last book published by Roger Zelazny, and tells of a group of Gothic horror characters, some familiar, some new, gathered together in the countryside near Victorian London, to undertake a mysterious ritual at Halloween involving Elder Gods and much more. It's a Gothic delight, and also like reading a gigantic chess puzzle in literary form. Each of the human participants in the Game has an animal companion, and the book is narrated by Jack the Ripper's dog Snuff.
Strictly speaking I should read it a chapter a day throughout October. I rarely manage it, though I tried pacing again this year, and still ended up gobbling it up far quicker. It's just so much fun. I also realised this time just how many favourite parts I have, as I was so happy to encounter them again.
This year we have also set my husband's boss onto reading it. He's a big Roger Zelazny fan, and has been interested in this book since Martin told him about it. This year a brand new 30th anniversary paperback edition was released, with new introduction by Neil Gaiman, my favourite living author. I had to upgrade my paperback copy to that (I also have a first edition hardback copy, much cherished), and so we passed on my copy to Martin's boss. Who was delighted to get it in hand just in time for October and a first read ...
So yes, a magnificent book, that I would recommend to anyone who likes a spooky tale, Gothic horror, or just plain good storytelling. Rereading it each year is a joy for me. Even if I can rarely pace myself to read it slowly!

The British Library in London is shortly to host a new exhibition Fantasy: Realms of Imagination. Would be great to see. There's also an accompanying exhibition book that can be bought. However even those at a distance can enjoy some of the many linked talks and events online. Either watching live online or streaming for 48 hours after each event. Here's the web page listing them all. I have just bought tickets for several.
Books finished in May 2023
Jun. 2nd, 2023 06:36 amInspired by posts elsewhere by some fellow book readers I thought it might be nice to look back on what I read this month. I probably won't manage this every month.
Here are the 10 books I finished in May:
Stardust by Neil Gaiman was this month's book club choice for me, a lovely fairy tale book, albeit somewhat different from the movie. I have reread this several times over the years.
Messy Roots graphic novel was a recommendation from the paid TBR service I treated myself to a subscription of. It's really interesting, showing how a family adapted moving from China to the US. And then there's the spectre of Covid as well - they had come from Wuhan many years earlier. Recommended, though I think it was maybe a bit more light in places than it might be.
Paul Magrs' latest Doctor Who book is lovely, a melancholy tale of an older Robin Hood and outlaws, with a clever timey wimey plot. A little too many different character points of view in places for me, but overall it was a strong read.
Percy Jackson book 1 was a quick fun read. I'm not sure I'll read any more in the series, but this was breezy stuff. It reminded me in many ways of Neil Gaiman's American Gods, but aimed at a younger audience.
The Donald Duck comic book was a quick read in the Comixology app on my iPad. Very funny retelling of the Man in the Iron Mask.
We love watching Pam Ayres on the telly so when we chanced on a signed copy of her latest rhyming poem picture book in our local bookshop we snapped it up, even if we are way over the target age range! It's really sweet though, and educational. And gorgeous otter pictures!
The Black Tulip by Alexandre Dumas was a surprise. Given its very short length by his standards I didn't expect the depth and twists in store. A gripping historical novel set in late 17th century Holland at the time of Tulipmania. An absolute gem.
I'm Scottish but haven't tried too many whiskies over the years. I have my favourites, especially Balvenie Caribbean Cask. Iain Banks's book Raw Spirit is a sprawling travelogue around Scotland, going to lots of whisky distilleries with stories of history, the places and tasting notes about the drinks. I now have a very long list of whiskies I want to try! It was a bit too rambling in places, very political as well which even though I share his politics got somewhat exasperating. Probably also a bit long. But still a good read.
Alongside the Dumas book my other standout highlight of the month was the book of David Bowie interview transcripts edited by Sean Egan. I read this on my Kindle and it's very long, but a fascinating insight into his life and career. The interviews span the 1960s to the early 2000s, and seeing how things evolved for him was intriguing. I did not expect to be so gripped by this. And I now want to explore more of his back catalogue of music.
Here are the 10 books I finished in May:
- Lord of Chaos (The Wheel of Time, #6) by Robert Jordan
- Stardust by Neil Gaiman
- Messy Roots: A Graphic Memoir of a Wuhanese American by Laura Gao
- Doctor Who The Return of Robin Hood by Paul Magrs
- Percy Jackson and the Lightning Thief by Rick Riordain
- Donald Duck, Duck in the Iron Mask by Disney (short comic)
- I am Oliver the Otter by Pam Ayres (picture book)
- The Black Tulip by Alexandre Dumas
- Raw Spirit: In Search of the Perfect Dram by Iain Banks
- Bowie on Bowie: Interviews and Encounters edited by Sean Egan (interviews collection)
Stardust by Neil Gaiman was this month's book club choice for me, a lovely fairy tale book, albeit somewhat different from the movie. I have reread this several times over the years.
Messy Roots graphic novel was a recommendation from the paid TBR service I treated myself to a subscription of. It's really interesting, showing how a family adapted moving from China to the US. And then there's the spectre of Covid as well - they had come from Wuhan many years earlier. Recommended, though I think it was maybe a bit more light in places than it might be.
Paul Magrs' latest Doctor Who book is lovely, a melancholy tale of an older Robin Hood and outlaws, with a clever timey wimey plot. A little too many different character points of view in places for me, but overall it was a strong read.
Percy Jackson book 1 was a quick fun read. I'm not sure I'll read any more in the series, but this was breezy stuff. It reminded me in many ways of Neil Gaiman's American Gods, but aimed at a younger audience.
The Donald Duck comic book was a quick read in the Comixology app on my iPad. Very funny retelling of the Man in the Iron Mask.
We love watching Pam Ayres on the telly so when we chanced on a signed copy of her latest rhyming poem picture book in our local bookshop we snapped it up, even if we are way over the target age range! It's really sweet though, and educational. And gorgeous otter pictures!
The Black Tulip by Alexandre Dumas was a surprise. Given its very short length by his standards I didn't expect the depth and twists in store. A gripping historical novel set in late 17th century Holland at the time of Tulipmania. An absolute gem.
I'm Scottish but haven't tried too many whiskies over the years. I have my favourites, especially Balvenie Caribbean Cask. Iain Banks's book Raw Spirit is a sprawling travelogue around Scotland, going to lots of whisky distilleries with stories of history, the places and tasting notes about the drinks. I now have a very long list of whiskies I want to try! It was a bit too rambling in places, very political as well which even though I share his politics got somewhat exasperating. Probably also a bit long. But still a good read.
Alongside the Dumas book my other standout highlight of the month was the book of David Bowie interview transcripts edited by Sean Egan. I read this on my Kindle and it's very long, but a fascinating insight into his life and career. The interviews span the 1960s to the early 2000s, and seeing how things evolved for him was intriguing. I did not expect to be so gripped by this. And I now want to explore more of his back catalogue of music.
Book 14 of 2023: Stardust by Neil Gaiman
May. 8th, 2023 02:13 amJust finished Stardust, a reread for me, and upgraded my rating from 4 to 5 stars. A very quick fun read, with gorgeous fairytale elements. I'm going to write some spoilers about this and the film version, so will put them in spoiler space. ( spoilers ) Really classical lyrical storytelling, but done in a way that isn't in your face. On the downside I could honestly have read more - it felt a little bit short, especially how it wrapped up. But I suppose that's a measure of how compelling it was. I wanted more.
This is the book this month for the book club run by a YouTuber I support on Patreon. I am intrigued to see what others make of it, especially those totally new to the story, who haven't read the book or seen the film before.
This is the book this month for the book club run by a YouTuber I support on Patreon. I am intrigued to see what others make of it, especially those totally new to the story, who haven't read the book or seen the film before.
Current reading May 2023
May. 4th, 2023 09:51 pmCraving a short and fun read after the epic 1000+ page plus Wheel of Time book, and given I'm flaring neurologically, I've picked Stardust by Neil Gaiman for my next read. This is a reread for me. It's not my absolute favourite of his, but I really enjoy it. Made into a great film of course, but it was an illustrated storybook first. This also is the month's read for a book club run by a YouTuber I back on Patreon.
As well as that I’m nearly finished the graphic novel Messy Roots, am most way through Iain Banks’ whisky trip around Scotland, and am slowly reading the rather long Bowie on Bowie interview book.

As well as that I’m nearly finished the graphic novel Messy Roots, am most way through Iain Banks’ whisky trip around Scotland, and am slowly reading the rather long Bowie on Bowie interview book.

Book 60 of 2022
Oct. 10th, 2022 10:04 amJust finished The Graveyard Book by Neil Gaiman, which was this month’s chosen book for a book club I’m in. This was a reread for me, and it’s my favourite book by my favourite living author.
It’s the tale of a young boy who survives a murder attempt as a baby and grows up in a graveyard, brought up by the ghosts. There are just 8 main chapters, spanning his childhood. Each one is slightly different in feel, but all a delight. The writing is strong throughout, but I’m especially struck by the tension of the opening and penultimate chapters. In the former the opening sentences are astonishingly effective in so few words.
The book deservedly won both the Carnegie and Newbery medals. Thoroughly recommended, and totally seasonally appropriate. An undoubted 5/5 stars from me.
It’s the tale of a young boy who survives a murder attempt as a baby and grows up in a graveyard, brought up by the ghosts. There are just 8 main chapters, spanning his childhood. Each one is slightly different in feel, but all a delight. The writing is strong throughout, but I’m especially struck by the tension of the opening and penultimate chapters. In the former the opening sentences are astonishingly effective in so few words.
The book deservedly won both the Carnegie and Newbery medals. Thoroughly recommended, and totally seasonally appropriate. An undoubted 5/5 stars from me.
Next reading
Oct. 2nd, 2022 11:12 pmPlanning my October fiction reading after I finish my current 2 novels. Thinking Neil Gaiman’s The Graveyard Book (a book club choice for me this month), Agatha Christie’s Hallowe’en Party, and Zelazny’s A Night In The Lonesome October (I read this every year). All rereads.
I have 2 fiction books on the go at the moment but am close to finishing them both. I also plan to soon start reading Rob Wilkins’ biography of Terry Pratchett.
Considering reading the new popular novel Babel in November.
I have 2 fiction books on the go at the moment but am close to finishing them both. I also plan to soon start reading Rob Wilkins’ biography of Terry Pratchett.
Considering reading the new popular novel Babel in November.
Book 43 of 2022
Jul. 18th, 2022 02:33 pmLast night I finished Lud-in-the-Mist by Hope Mirrlees. This book was published in 1926 and I’d been meaning to read it ever since I heard Neil Gaiman praise it effusively in person. I finally got round to it after a book YouTuber I follow, Christy Anne Jones in Australia, read and enjoyed it, and reminded me of it in the process. I was delighted to be able to get a new edition of it for my Kindle.
It’s set in a fantasy world that feels almost Victorian or earlier. Christy likened the feel of the book to Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell, which I think is very apt. In this world a country and its people live next to the land of fairies. Which they regard with suspicion and fear. And the book recounts how the two end up interacting, viewed primarily through the eyes of the local mayor in the country’s largest town.
It is very readable but I found I needed a little while initially to adapt to the old style storytelling. However once I did and it “clicked” I found it utterly charming and was thoroughly enchanted by it. The story itself is delightful, feeling very like a folk tale or ballad from the past. The cast of characters encountered are lively and entertaining, often provoking amusement. And there is a strong feel of magic running throughout.
It’s easy to see how influential this novel was on Neil Gaiman. Most obviously in his novel Stardust, which also sees a country abutting the fairy world. But also in some of his other works, such as Neverwhere.
I am already missing the world of this novel! I am sure that I will reread it again.
A thoroughly recommended 5/5 rating.
It’s set in a fantasy world that feels almost Victorian or earlier. Christy likened the feel of the book to Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell, which I think is very apt. In this world a country and its people live next to the land of fairies. Which they regard with suspicion and fear. And the book recounts how the two end up interacting, viewed primarily through the eyes of the local mayor in the country’s largest town.
It is very readable but I found I needed a little while initially to adapt to the old style storytelling. However once I did and it “clicked” I found it utterly charming and was thoroughly enchanted by it. The story itself is delightful, feeling very like a folk tale or ballad from the past. The cast of characters encountered are lively and entertaining, often provoking amusement. And there is a strong feel of magic running throughout.
It’s easy to see how influential this novel was on Neil Gaiman. Most obviously in his novel Stardust, which also sees a country abutting the fairy world. But also in some of his other works, such as Neverwhere.
I am already missing the world of this novel! I am sure that I will reread it again.
A thoroughly recommended 5/5 rating.